Free consultation (908) 588-7217
Row of brownstone houses on a tree-lined street in Brooklyn

Child Custody in New York City

Pascelle Saint-Laurent is a New York child custody lawyer for parents in all five boroughs. In New York there is no prima facie right to custody in either parent; the court decides what is in the child’s best interest. Custody can be decided in a divorce in the Supreme Court, or by petition in Family Court.

Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment

Quick answer

What standard governs New York child custody decisions?

The best interests of the child. New York law says neither parent has a prima facie right to custody, and the court decides what best promotes the child’s welfare (DRL §§ 70, 240). Where domestic violence is alleged in a sworn pleading (such as a sworn petition or answer) and proven, the court must consider its effect on the child’s best interests.

  • Best interests of the child
  • No preference for either parent
  • Supreme Court or Family Court

Key facts

Standard
The best interests of the child (DRL §§ 70, 240)
Parents
No prima facie right to custody in either parent (DRL § 70)
In a divorce
Decided in the Supreme Court (DRL § 240)
Without a divorce
A petition in Family Court (Family Court Act § 651)
Domestic violence
Proven allegations must be considered (DRL § 240(1)(a))
Which state
The child’s home state, with exceptions (DRL § 76)

The standard

The best-interests standard in New York

A New York court decides custody solely on the best interests of the child, and neither parent has a prima facie right to custody. Custody covers major decisions about the child and where the child lives, and the table shows the two parts.

Parts of a New York custody arrangement
PartWhat it covers
Legal custodyMajor decisions, such as education, medical care and religious upbringing; sole or joint
Physical custodyWhere the child mainly lives, with a parenting time schedule for the other parent

Under DRL § 70 there is no prima facie right to custody in either parent, and the court determines solely what is for the best interest of the child and what will best promote the child’s welfare and happiness. DRL § 240 applies the same best-interests test when custody is decided in a matrimonial action.

What the court weighs

What a New York court weighs

A New York court weighs each parent’s role, the child’s stability, each parent’s support for the child’s bond with the other parent, and any domestic violence. Records help show each point.

  • Each parent’s role

    Who has been caring for the child, and how each parent meets the child’s needs.

  • Stability

    Schooling, community ties and the continuity of the child’s routine.

  • The other parent

    Each parent’s willingness to support the child’s relationship with the other parent.

  • Domestic violence

    Where it is alleged in a sworn pleading and proven by a preponderance of the evidence (a standard of proof of 50 percent plus), the court must consider its effect on the child’s best interests (DRL § 240(1)(a)).

  • The child’s views

    Depending on age and maturity, the child’s wishes can be part of the picture.

  • Safety checks

    The court reviews the statewide registry of orders of protection and the sex offender registry before deciding custody or visitation (DRL § 240(1)(a-1)).

Which court

Supreme Court or Family Court

A New York custody case is heard in the Supreme Court in a divorce, or in Family Court by petition when there is no divorce. Both courts apply the same best-interests standard.

In a divorce

In a matrimonial action, the Supreme Court enters orders for custody and support as justice requires, having regard to the best interests of the child (DRL § 240).

Without a divorce

Custody and visitation can be brought by petition in Family Court, which applies DRL § 240 with the same powers as the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court can also refer custody matters to Family Court (Family Court Act § 651).

When another state is involved

Under New York’s UCCJEA (the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act), the first basis for an initial custody determination is that New York is the child’s home state, or was within six months before the case and a parent still lives here. The other bases apply only when no state is the home state under that rule or the home state declines jurisdiction; temporary emergency jurisdiction is separate (DRL §§ 76, 76-c). See moving between NJ and NY with children.

How a case works

How a custody case works, and where a lawyer helps

A New York custody case runs in four steps: choose the court, propose a parenting plan, the court’s safety review and the order. A lawyer can prepare each step with you and explain your options.

  1. Choose the court

    The Supreme Court in a divorce, or a Family Court petition.

  2. Propose a plan

    Decision-making, a residential schedule, holidays and exchanges.

  3. Safety review

    The court checks the registries before it decides.

  4. The order

    An agreed plan or the court’s decision becomes the order.

Common questions

New York custody questions

These questions cover the best-interests standard, legal and physical custody, whether either parent is favored, domestic violence, which court hears the case and changing an order.

What is the best-interests-of-the-child standard in New York?

It is the test for every custody decision. The court determines solely what is for the best interest of the child and what will best promote the child’s welfare and happiness. Source: DRL §§ 70, 240

What is the difference between legal custody and physical custody in New York?

Legal custody refers to major decisions, such as education, medical care and religious upbringing. Physical custody refers to where the child mainly lives. Either can be sole or joint.

Does New York favor mothers in custody cases?

No. The statute says there is no prima facie right to the custody of the child in either parent. Source: DRL § 70

How does domestic violence affect a custody case in New York?

Where a party alleges domestic violence in a sworn pleading and proves it by a preponderance of the evidence, the court must consider its effect on the child’s best interests. Source: DRL § 240(1)(a)

Can custody be decided in Family Court instead of Supreme Court?

Yes. Custody and visitation can be brought by petition in Family Court, which applies DRL § 240 with the same powers as the Supreme Court. In a divorce, the Supreme Court decides custody. Source: Family Court Act § 651

How is a New York custody order modified?

The court that made the order can modify it, and the best-interests standard applies. Ask a lawyer what you need to show in your situation. Source: DRL § 240(1)(a)

What is a parenting plan or parenting time schedule in New York?

It is the arrangement set out in detail: the residential schedule, holidays and vacations, decision-making, and how disputes are resolved. Parents who agree can ask the court to make it part of the order; otherwise the court decides.

How much does a child custody lawyer cost in New York City?

It depends on whether custody is contested and how much work the case needs. Ask about the fee arrangement in writing before work begins.

Your attorney

About the attorney

Pascelle Saint-Laurent, Esq., New Jersey and New York attorney

Pascelle Saint-Laurent, Esq. handles New York custody and parenting time matters in the Supreme Court and in Family Court for parents in all five boroughs.

She is admitted in New York and New Jersey. Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment.

She acts for people on both sides of a case, and she also handles New Jersey family matters in the Family Part of the Superior Court.

Admitted
New Jersey (2008) and New York (2009)
Education
J.D., Brooklyn Law School. LL.M., University of Miami School of Law
Mailing address
971 US-202, Ste 6717, Branchburg, NJ 08876

New York City courts: NYC Family Court and Supreme Court in the five boroughs

Client reviews

What clients say

Reviews below are from Google. They describe working with Pascelle Saint-Laurent in general, not any one practice area. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. See all reviews on Google (opens in a new tab)

Posted on Google Google
danny laurenti profile picture
danny laurenti
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had a great experience with Next Step Lawyer. Pascelle helped me with a traffic ticket and made the whole process much easier than I expected. She was kind, professional, easy to talk to, and kept me informed throughout everything. I really appreciated how helpful and straightforward she was from start to finish. I’d recommend their services to anyone who needs help.
Posted on Google Google
Elizabeth Chirveno profile picture
Elizabeth Chirveno
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Highly recommend Pascelle! She’s tough and can hold her own yet very easy to talk to. She listened carefully to my case and was very knowledgeable. She helped me achieve my ideal outcome and I’m very grateful
Posted on Google Google
Toni Marissa profile picture
Toni Marissa
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Pascelle has the capability of leading with compassion for you as her client while also fighting passionately and aggressively for the results you deserve. Her knowledge and talents are a refreshing grounding element during what are difficult times. She has the ability to explain complex legal challenges in transparent and accessible language, and outlines clear strategies to set you up for the most ideal outcomes. Can’t thank her enough.
Posted on Google Google
Lena Watkins profile picture
Lena Watkins
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Extremely professional (responds quickly, attention to detail, supportive)! Most importantly, Pascelle is incredibly thorough and informative so that every possibility is on the table for a grounded strategy in considering best possible outcomes. I can't thank her enough for what she's done for my family. Highly recommend!
Posted on Google Google
Danielle Rivers profile picture
Danielle Rivers
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Beyond helpful! Beyond knowledgeable! She answered all my questions with compassion and empathy but also answers that never pushed more than the outcome I wanted.

Next step

Talk to a lawyer about custody

If you need a custody or parenting time arrangement in New York, or want to change one, the attorney can explain your options and the next steps.

Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM. Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment. Prefer to write? Submit your details.

We aim to reply within one business hour. Response times are not guaranteed. Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM. Please don't send confidential details here. Chat replies aren't legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is formed until a written engagement agreement is signed.