Free consultation (908) 588-7217
Row of brownstone houses on a tree-lined street in Brooklyn

Modifying Child Support and Maintenance in New York

Pascelle Saint-Laurent is a New York family lawyer who helps parents and former spouses in all five boroughs change child support and maintenance orders. An order stays in force until a court changes it. Child support that came due before you apply cannot be reduced, so timing matters.

Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment

Quick answer

Can child support or maintenance be changed in New York?

Yes, if you show a ground the law accepts. Child support can be changed for a substantial change in circumstances and, unless your agreement opts out, after three years or a 15% change in either parent’s gross income. Maintenance ordered after a trial can change on a substantial change in circumstances. Maintenance under an agreement still in force needs extreme hardship (DRL § 236(B)(9); Family Court Act § 451).

  • Substantial change
  • Three years or 15%
  • No cut to past-due support

Key facts

Law
DRL § 236(B)(9); Family Court Act § 451
Child support
Substantial change, three years, or a 15% income change
Opt-out
The three-year and 15% grounds can be opted out of in writing
Maintenance
Substantial change after trial; extreme hardship under an agreement
Arrears
Child support due before you apply cannot be reduced
Which court
Depends on the order (Family Court Act § 466)

Child support

When child support can be changed

A New York child support order can be changed on a substantial change in circumstances, after three years, or when either parent’s gross income changes by 15% or more. The table shows which ground may fit.

Grounds for changing a New York child support order
GroundWhat must be shown
Substantial changeA substantial change in circumstances, including for an order that incorporates the parents’ agreement without merging it
Three yearsThree years have passed since the order was entered, last modified or adjusted, unless the parents opted out
15% income changeEither parent’s gross income changed by 15% or more since then, unless the parents opted out

A drop in income counts only if it was involuntary and the parent has made diligent attempts to find work that fits their education, ability and experience. Incarceration is not treated as voluntary unemployment and does not bar a finding of a substantial change (DRL § 236(B)(9)(b)(2); Family Court Act § 451(3)).

Maintenance and agreements

Changing maintenance, and orders based on an agreement

Whether maintenance can be changed depends on where the terms came from. Maintenance from an agreement still in force can be changed only on a showing of extreme hardship, so an agreement can make a change harder.

  • Maintenance after a trial

    The court may change or end it if the payee cannot be self-supporting, or on a substantial change in circumstances, including financial hardship.

  • The payor retires

    Actual full or partial retirement of the payor can count, if it results in a substantial change in finances.

  • An agreement still in force

    Maintenance from the agreement can be changed only on a showing of extreme hardship on either party.

  • Past-due maintenance

    Arrears reduced to a final judgment cannot be reduced; other arrears only on good cause for not applying sooner.

  • Child support in an agreement

    An order that incorporates the agreement without merging it can still change on a substantial change.

  • Opting out

    A valid written agreement can opt out of the three-year and 15% grounds for child support.

These rules are in DRL § 236(B)(9)(b). An agreement that sets child support above or below the basic amount must state that amount and the reason for the difference (DRL § 240(1-b)(h)).

Which court

Family Court or Supreme Court

A Family Court support order is changed in Family Court, while a Supreme Court divorce order may say which court can modify it. Checking your judgment first saves a wrong filing.

  • A Family Court support order is changed in Family Court. You start by filing a petition that alleges facts meeting one of the grounds (Family Court Act § 451(2)).
  • A Supreme Court divorce order may say that only Family Court can enforce or modify it, or that only Supreme Court can (Family Court Act § 466(a), (b)).
  • If the divorce order says neither, Family Court may hear an application to modify maintenance on a later change of circumstances (§ 466(c)).

Keep paying under the current order while you wait. It stays in force until the court changes it, and child support that comes due before you apply cannot be reduced later.

Arrears and enforcement

What happens to unpaid support

A change in the order cannot reduce child support that was already owed before you applied. Asking promptly protects you if your income has dropped.

Past-due child support

A modification cannot reduce or annul child support arrears that accrued before the application (Family Court Act § 451(1); DRL § 236(B)(9)(b)(2)(iii)).

Increases back to the application date

A modification may increase support back to the date of the application if it is based on newly discovered evidence. Any retroactive amount is paid in one sum or periodic sums, as the court directs.

Enforcement

Orders in matrimonial actions can be enforced by income execution and in other ways the law provides. If a party fails to pay maintenance, a distributive award or child support, the court must, after notice and a chance to be heard, require security or the sequestering and sale of assets (DRL § 236(B)(9)(a)).

Preparing

Getting ready to ask for a change

Gather the current order, the date it was last changed and proof of your income then and now. The person asking for the change has to show the ground.

  • the current order or judgment, and any agreement it includes;
  • the date the order was entered or last changed, for the three-year rule;
  • pay stubs and tax returns from then and now, for the 15% rule;
  • proof of what changed, such as a layoff notice, medical records or new child care costs; and
  • if your income fell, records of your job search.

How a case works

How a support change works, and where a lawyer helps

A request to change support follows four steps: read your order, gather records, file promptly and wait for the decision. A lawyer can tell you which test fits your order and which court to ask.

  1. Read your order

    Which court, and any opt-out of the three-year and 15% grounds.

  2. Gather records

    Income then and now, and proof of what changed.

  3. File promptly

    A petition or application that states the ground.

  4. The decision

    The court decides whether the ground is shown.

Common questions

New York support modification questions

These questions cover the three-year rule, paying while you wait, job loss, agreements, retirement, which court to use and increases back in time.

Does child support change on its own every three years?

No. After three years, a court may change the order if a parent applies, unless the parents opted out of this ground in a valid written agreement. Source: Family Court Act § 451(3)(b); DRL § 236(B)(9)(b)(2)(ii)

Can I stop paying while I ask for a change?

No. The order stays in force until the court changes it. Child support that comes due before you apply cannot be reduced later. Source: Family Court Act § 451(1)

Does losing my job count as a change?

It can. A drop in income counts only if it was involuntary and you have made diligent attempts to find work that fits your education, ability and experience. Source: Family Court Act § 451(3)(b)

My maintenance comes from our divorce agreement. Can it be changed?

If the agreement is still in force, the court may change maintenance only on a showing of extreme hardship on either party. That is a stricter test than for maintenance ordered after a trial. Source: DRL § 236(B)(9)(b)(1)

Can retirement reduce maintenance?

For maintenance ordered after a trial, the payor’s actual full or partial retirement can be a ground, if it results in a substantial change in financial circumstances. Source: DRL § 236(B)(9)(b)(1)

Which court do I file in?

A Family Court order is changed by a petition in Family Court. For a Supreme Court divorce order, check what it says: it may send changes to Family Court, keep them in Supreme Court, or say neither. Source: Family Court Act §§ 451(2), 466

Can child support be raised back to an earlier date?

An increase can go back to the date of the application if it is based on newly discovered evidence. Any retroactive amount is paid in one sum or periodic sums, as the court directs. Source: DRL § 236(B)(9)(b)(2)(iii)

Your attorney

About the attorney

Pascelle Saint-Laurent, Esq., New Jersey and New York attorney

Pascelle Saint-Laurent, Esq. handles requests to change child support and maintenance in New York City Family Court and Supreme Court for people in all five boroughs.

She is admitted in New York and New Jersey. Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment.

She acts for people on both sides of a case, and she also handles New Jersey family matters in the Family Part of the Superior Court.

Admitted
New Jersey (2008) and New York (2009)
Education
J.D., Brooklyn Law School. LL.M., University of Miami School of Law
Mailing address
971 US-202, Ste 6717, Branchburg, NJ 08876

New York City courts: NYC Family Court and Supreme Court in the five boroughs

Client reviews

What clients say

Reviews below are from Google. They describe working with Pascelle Saint-Laurent in general, not any one practice area. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. See all reviews on Google (opens in a new tab)

Posted on Google Google
danny laurenti profile picture
danny laurenti
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had a great experience with Next Step Lawyer. Pascelle helped me with a traffic ticket and made the whole process much easier than I expected. She was kind, professional, easy to talk to, and kept me informed throughout everything. I really appreciated how helpful and straightforward she was from start to finish. I’d recommend their services to anyone who needs help.
Posted on Google Google
Elizabeth Chirveno profile picture
Elizabeth Chirveno
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Highly recommend Pascelle! She’s tough and can hold her own yet very easy to talk to. She listened carefully to my case and was very knowledgeable. She helped me achieve my ideal outcome and I’m very grateful
Posted on Google Google
Toni Marissa profile picture
Toni Marissa
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Pascelle has the capability of leading with compassion for you as her client while also fighting passionately and aggressively for the results you deserve. Her knowledge and talents are a refreshing grounding element during what are difficult times. She has the ability to explain complex legal challenges in transparent and accessible language, and outlines clear strategies to set you up for the most ideal outcomes. Can’t thank her enough.
Posted on Google Google
Lena Watkins profile picture
Lena Watkins
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Extremely professional (responds quickly, attention to detail, supportive)! Most importantly, Pascelle is incredibly thorough and informative so that every possibility is on the table for a grounded strategy in considering best possible outcomes. I can't thank her enough for what she's done for my family. Highly recommend!
Posted on Google Google
Danielle Rivers profile picture
Danielle Rivers
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Beyond helpful! Beyond knowledgeable! She answered all my questions with compassion and empathy but also answers that never pushed more than the outcome I wanted.

Next step

Talk to a lawyer about changing support

If your income or your family’s needs have changed, the attorney can explain which test applies to your order, which court to ask and the next steps.

Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM. Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment. Prefer to write? Submit your details.

We aim to reply within one business hour. Response times are not guaranteed. Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM. Please don't send confidential details here. Chat replies aren't legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is formed until a written engagement agreement is signed.