Free consultation (908) 588-7217
Federal courthouse and government offices at Government Center in Newark, New Jersey

Adverse Employment Action Lawyer in New Jersey

Pascelle Saint-Laurent helps New Jersey employees work out whether what happened at work counts as an adverse employment action. Not every unpleasant change does, and some that seem small can.

Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment

Quick answer

What counts as an adverse employment action in NJ?

An adverse employment action is a step that harms your job, such as a firing, suspension, demotion, or worse pay or working conditions. The NJLAD (the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination) bars discrimination in pay and in the terms and conditions of work, and CEPA (the New Jersey whistleblower law) defines retaliatory action to include discharge, suspension, demotion or other adverse action. In retaliation cases, courts use a broader test.

  • Firing or demotion
  • Pay or conditions
  • Broader for retaliation

Key facts

Discrimination rule
No discharge, or discrimination in pay or terms of employment, because of a protected trait (N.J.S.A. 10:5-12(a))
Retaliation rule
No reprisals for opposing discrimination (N.J.S.A. 10:5-12(d))
CEPA definition
Discharge, suspension, demotion or other adverse employment action (N.J.S.A. 34:19-2(e))
Deadlines
CEPA 1 year; NJLAD 2 years in court or 180 days at the Division on Civil Rights
Where it is heard
Superior Court, Law Division, or the Division on Civil Rights

The tests

What counts as an adverse employment action in New Jersey

In New Jersey, the classic adverse actions are a firing, a demotion and a cut in pay or hours, but what counts depends on the kind of claim. The same event can qualify in one claim and not another, so it is a defined question rather than a matter of how bad it felt.

Adverse employment action tests in New Jersey
Type of claimWhat can qualifyWhere the rule comes from
Discrimination (NJLAD)Firing, refusing to hire or promote, or treating someone worse in pay or in the terms, conditions or privileges of employmentN.J.S.A. 10:5-12(a) (the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination)
Whistleblower retaliation (CEPA)Discharge, suspension, demotion, or other adverse employment action in the terms and conditions of employmentN.J.S.A. 34:19-2(e)
Retaliation for a discrimination complaint (NJLAD)Reprisals, such as firing, demoting or otherwise penalizing someone for reporting discrimination or harassment. Retaliation can include, but is not limited to, being discharged, demoted, not hired, not promoted or disciplined, and many relatively minor incidents can combine into a patternN.J.S.A. 10:5-12(d); NJ Division on Civil Rights; NJ Model Civil Jury Charge 2.22
Retaliation under federal law (Title VII)Action a reasonable employee would find materially adverse, meaning it well might have dissuaded a reasonable worker from making or supporting a charge of discriminationBurlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. White, 548 U.S. 53, 68 (2006)

The classic adverse actions are a firing, a demotion, and a cut in pay or hours. In a retaliation case, smaller changes such as exclusion from meetings, unwarranted write-ups or a sudden schedule change are worth recording, because New Jersey’s model jury charge recognizes that minor incidents can add up to a pattern. If working conditions were made so intolerable that you felt forced to quit, the law may treat that like a firing; an attorney can look at the facts.

Examples

Examples of adverse action at work

Firing, suspension, demotion, a pay cut, a transfer to a worse job, a lost promotion and discipline after a complaint can all count as adverse actions. Whether an example qualifies depends on the facts and the kind of claim.

  • Firing or suspension

    The clearest examples. CEPA lists discharge and suspension as retaliatory action.

  • Demotion or a worse title

    A demotion, or moving someone to a role with less responsibility, is listed in CEPA’s definition.

  • Cut pay, hours or benefits

    The NJLAD bars discrimination in compensation. A cut in pay, hours or benefits can be an adverse action.

  • A transfer to a worse job

    A move to a less desirable position, shift or location can affect the terms and conditions of work.

  • Passed over for a promotion

    Refusing to promote someone because of a protected trait is a discrimination claim under the NJLAD.

  • Discipline after a complaint

    Write-ups for conduct that was tolerated before, appearing only after a complaint, can support a retaliation claim.

  • Cut out of meetings or projects

    In a retaliation case, being excluded from work you used to do can matter, especially if it began right after you spoke up.

  • A poor review with consequences

    Whether a negative review counts depends on the facts, such as whether it led to a lost raise or a performance plan.

Read more: retaliation in New Jersey and workplace discrimination in New Jersey.

Deadlines

Which deadline applies after an adverse action

After an adverse action, you have one year for a CEPA lawsuit, two years for an NJLAD lawsuit or 180 days at the Division on Civil Rights, and 300 days for an EEOC charge. The deadlines run from the action itself, such as the demotion or the firing.

A CEPA lawsuit must be filed within one year (N.J.S.A. 34:19-5). An NJLAD lawsuit must be filed within two years of the violation, or a complaint can go to the Division on Civil Rights within 180 days (N.J.S.A. 10:5-18). A federal claim needs an EEOC charge within 300 days (42 U.S.C. 2000e-5).

Count from the action, not from when you realized it was unfair. If you are unsure which date governs, treat the earliest likely date as your deadline.

See filing deadlines for New Jersey employment claims for every clock.

Documenting it

How to document an adverse action

Save the emails, reviews and HR messages, and note the timing, the decision-maker and how others were treated. Notes made at the time record details before memory fades, and none of this commits you to a claim.

Keep the record

Save emails, reviews, write-ups and HR messages as soon as the action happens, somewhere other than a work device. Access to work systems can end quickly. See preserving evidence in a New Jersey employment case.

Note the timing

Write down the date of the action and how it relates to any complaint, report, leave request or other protected activity.

Identify the decision-maker

Note who made the decision and whether that person knew about your complaint or report.

Compare treatment

Note how others in a similar position were treated for the same conduct. Differences can show that the stated reason is not the real one.

Next steps

What to do after an adverse employment action in NJ

After a demotion, pay cut or similar change, write down what changed, keep the papers, link it to the cause and check the deadline. These steps protect your options without committing you to anything, and you can start the first two today.

  1. Write down what changed

    The date, what was done and who decided it.

  2. Keep the papers

    Save notices, reviews and messages outside work systems.

  3. Link it to the cause

    Note any complaint, leave request or protected trait involved.

  4. Check the deadline

    One year for CEPA; two years, or 180 days at the Division, for the NJLAD.

Common questions

Adverse employment action questions

These questions cover adverse employment action in New Jersey: classic examples, performance reviews, the retaliation test, exclusion, constructive discharge and documentation.

What are the classic examples of adverse employment action in NJ?

A firing, suspension or demotion, a cut in pay or hours, a transfer to a worse position and a denied promotion. The NJLAD bars discharge and discrimination in compensation or in the terms, conditions or privileges of employment, and CEPA lists discharge, suspension and demotion as retaliatory action. Source: N.J.S.A. 10:5-12(a); N.J.S.A. 34:19-2(e)

Does a bad performance review count as an adverse action?

Not automatically. Whether it counts depends on the facts, such as whether it led to a tangible consequence: a lost raise or bonus, a performance plan leading to dismissal, or a blocked promotion. In a retaliation case, a sudden poor review right after a complaint is worth recording.

What is the standard for adverse action in a retaliation claim?

It depends on the law. Under the federal anti-discrimination law, Title VII, the U.S. Supreme Court has held that the action must be one a reasonable employee would find materially adverse, meaning it well might have dissuaded a reasonable worker from making or supporting a charge of discrimination.

Under the NJLAD, New Jersey’s model jury charge says retaliation can include, but is not limited to, being discharged, demoted, not hired, not promoted or disciplined, and that many relatively minor incidents can combine into a pattern. CEPA’s own definition covers discharge, suspension, demotion or other adverse employment action in the terms and conditions of employment. Source: Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. White, 548 U.S. 53, 68 (2006); NJ Model Civil Jury Charge 2.22; N.J.S.A. 34:19-2(e)

Can exclusion from meetings or projects be an adverse action?

It can, particularly in a retaliation case where it began shortly after you complained. New Jersey’s model jury charge recognizes that relatively minor incidents can combine into a pattern. Source: NJ Model Civil Jury Charge 2.22

What is constructive discharge in NJ?

It is the term for being pushed out of a job. If working conditions were made so intolerable that you felt forced to quit, the law may treat that like a firing; an attorney can look at the facts.

Is penalizing me for a discrimination complaint an adverse action?

Yes. The NJLAD bars reprisals against anyone who opposed practices the law forbids. An employer cannot fire, demote or otherwise penalize an employee for reporting discrimination or harassment to human resources or to the Division on Civil Rights. Source: N.J.S.A. 10:5-12(d); NJ Division on Civil Rights

How do I document an adverse action?

At the time, and away from company systems. Save emails, texts, reviews, write-ups and HR messages, and write down the date of the action, who decided it and how it relates to any complaint you made.

How long do I have to act after an adverse action in NJ?

A CEPA lawsuit must be filed within one year. An NJLAD lawsuit must be filed within two years of the violation, or a Division on Civil Rights complaint within 180 days. Source: N.J.S.A. 34:19-5; NJ Division on Civil Rights; N.J.S.A. 10:5-18

Your attorney

About the attorney

Pascelle Saint-Laurent, Esq., New Jersey and New York attorney

Pascelle Saint-Laurent, Esq. represents employees in New Jersey discrimination and retaliation matters that turn on demotions, pay cuts, discipline and other adverse actions, in the Law Division of the Superior Court and before the Division on Civil Rights. She acts for employees, not employers.

Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment, for clients across New Jersey and New York City. She is also admitted in New York.

Every employment matter starts with the record: the offer letter, reviews, discipline, the termination notice and any severance agreement. The laws that may apply, such as the NJLAD, CEPA, the Wage Payment Law and the FMLA, decide what the employer had to do.

Admitted
New Jersey (2008) and New York (2009)
Education
J.D., Brooklyn Law School. LL.M., University of Miami School of Law
Mailing address
971 US-202, Ste 6717, Branchburg, NJ 08876

Law Division courthouses: Somerset (Somerville), Middlesex (New Brunswick), Union (Elizabeth) and Mercer (Trenton)

Client reviews

What clients say

Reviews below are from Google. They describe working with Pascelle Saint-Laurent in general, not any one practice area. Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. See all reviews on Google (opens in a new tab)

Posted on Google Google
danny laurenti profile picture
danny laurenti
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had a great experience with Next Step Lawyer. Pascelle helped me with a traffic ticket and made the whole process much easier than I expected. She was kind, professional, easy to talk to, and kept me informed throughout everything. I really appreciated how helpful and straightforward she was from start to finish. I’d recommend their services to anyone who needs help.
Posted on Google Google
Elizabeth Chirveno profile picture
Elizabeth Chirveno
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Highly recommend Pascelle! She’s tough and can hold her own yet very easy to talk to. She listened carefully to my case and was very knowledgeable. She helped me achieve my ideal outcome and I’m very grateful
Posted on Google Google
Toni Marissa profile picture
Toni Marissa
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Pascelle has the capability of leading with compassion for you as her client while also fighting passionately and aggressively for the results you deserve. Her knowledge and talents are a refreshing grounding element during what are difficult times. She has the ability to explain complex legal challenges in transparent and accessible language, and outlines clear strategies to set you up for the most ideal outcomes. Can’t thank her enough.
Posted on Google Google
Lena Watkins profile picture
Lena Watkins
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Extremely professional (responds quickly, attention to detail, supportive)! Most importantly, Pascelle is incredibly thorough and informative so that every possibility is on the table for a grounded strategy in considering best possible outcomes. I can't thank her enough for what she's done for my family. Highly recommend!
Posted on Google Google
Danielle Rivers profile picture
Danielle Rivers
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Beyond helpful! Beyond knowledgeable! She answered all my questions with compassion and empathy but also answers that never pushed more than the outcome I wanted.

Next step

Talk to a lawyer about a change at work

If you were demoted, cut back or pushed aside and are not sure it was lawful, the attorney can look at what happened and walk you through your options.

Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM. Consultations by phone, video or in person by appointment. Prefer to write? Submit your details.

We aim to reply within one business hour. Response times are not guaranteed. Monday to Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:30 PM. Please don't send confidential details here. Chat replies aren't legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is formed until a written engagement agreement is signed.